|
THE
WESTERN CHRISTIAN TERRORISM AGAINST THE ARABS:
THE CANNIBALISM AND
BLOODBATHS OF THE CRUSADES
(1095-1291)
By: Dr.
Abdullah Mohammad Sindi*
(Ph.D. International Relations)
I.
Introduction
It is in these
lawless and dangerous times when Prophet Mohammad is
being viciously attacked as a “terrorist” in Western
caricatures, and when Arabs and Muslims are being
reviled throughout the West as “terrorists”, “fanatics”,
“fascists”, and “intolerant”, that it becomes necessary
(lest we forget) to recall the past Western Christian
terrorism of the Crusades against the Arabs. This
well-documented record of the cannibalistic and barbaric
Crusaders, which is well known in the Arab world, is
rather obscure to most Westerners because it is either
conveniently concealed or deeply buried in some
unnoticed specialized books.
When US
President George W. Bush (who speaks to God) said in
2001 - in response to the terrorist attacks of 9-11 -
that the US was waging a “Crusade” on Arab and Muslim
“terrorism”, he was actually conjuring up the old
nightmarish horrors of the Western terrorist Crusades
against the Arabs. However, because of widespread angry
reactions across the Arab and Muslim worlds to Bush’s
use of the word “Crusade”, the American Government was
forced to replace it with the word “war”. Regardless,
the current American illegal and brutal wars on
Afghanistan and Iraq are indeed very similar to the past
Western terrorist Crusades. Apparently when it comes to
Western dealings with Arabs and Muslims the old saying
still stands: the more things change, the more they
remain the same.
II. The Crusades:
A General Overview
Of all the
religious wars in human history waged by any religion,
at any place, and at any time, none have been
bloodier, more genocidal, more barbaric, and more
protracted than the 200-year "holy wars" by the Western
Crusades against the Arabs and Islam. The Western
Crusaders horrifically soaked Asia Minor and the Eastern
Arab Mediterranean coast with Arab blood (both Muslim
and Jewish). The objective of the Crusades was simple,
to destroy the Arabs (whether Muslim or Jew) in the Holy
Land of Palestine and its environs "…on the ground that
they had no right to inhabit their part of the earth,
while for a Christian the whole world is his country."
[1]
Unlike Muslims
(Arab and non-Arab) who have always tolerated Christians
and Jews (Arab and non-Arab), married into them, and
lived and worked with them side by side in peace as
"People of the Book" in all Arab and Muslim lands as
well as in old Arab Andalusia (Spain and Portugal), the
Christian West has had no desire to coexist with Islam
and the Arabs. Also, unlike Muslims who revere Moses and
Jesus as God’s prophets, most Christians and Jews in the
“tolerant” West have no respect for Prophet Mohammad and
are rudely contemptuous of him and Islam. In fact ever
since its birth and its subsequent widespread expansion,
Islam has been looked upon in the West as a mortal
danger, both moral and military, to be strongly opposed
or even destroyed. In his classic exposé of Christian
violence worldwide, A History of Christianity,
the Western Christian scholar Paul Johnson rejects the
Western propaganda about Islam’s “violent” expansion by
stating that: "The success of Islam sprang essentially
from the failure of Christian theologians to solve the
problem of the Trinity and Christ's nature." [2]
Nevertheless,
the Western Crusades' insane bloodbaths against the
Arabs were triggered by the decisive defeat of the
Byzantine army in 1071 at the hands of the Turkish
Seljuk (Abbasid) army. Fearing that all of Asia Minor
would be quickly overrun by the Abbasids, the defeated
Byzantine emperor, Alexius I, quickly appealed to his
Christian rivals and opponents in Western Europe, i.e.,
Pope Urban II and his other "fellow" Christian rulers,
to come to the aid of Constantinople by undertaking a
"pilgrimage" or Crusade to "free" Jerusalem and the rest
of Palestine from Arab and Muslim rule.
Emperor Alexius'
appeal provided Pope Urban II with his lifetime
opportunity to gain more recognition and power for the
papal authority and for its role in legitimizing the
temporal actions of the West European kings. Presiding
over an urgent Church Council meeting, at Piacenza,
Italy, in March 1095, Pope Urban II - with the Byzantine
ambassador sitting next to him - called upon all the
Western European followers of Christ to do "God's will”
by carrying arms to "liberate the Holy Land" and cleanse
it from the desecration of the Arab and Muslim
"infidels." The Pope's call to fight the Arabs was
ironic because, as scholar Francis Peters observed "God
may indeed have wished it, but there is certainly no
evidence that the Christians of Jerusalem did, or that
anything extraordinary was occurring to pilgrims there
to prompt such a response at that moment in history."
[3] Although Christian and Jewish pilgrims (Arab and
non-Arab) were burdened by taxes; they were never barred
or even restricted from their religious shrines in
Jerusalem either by Muslim Arab or Turkish authorities,
even during the few severe sporadic civil disturbances
in Palestine. In fact, Arabs (Muslims, Jews, and
Christians) as well as non-Arabs (also Muslims, Jews,
and Christians) have all lived together in Palestine in
peace under Islamic rule since the dawn of Islam.
In reality,
however, the veritable rationale behind launching the
Crusades went beyond religious impulses, which were
mostly the concern of the common people. Western kings,
knights, feudal lords, and merchants were driven
primarily by political, military, and commercial
ambitions as well as by the prospects of new lands and
riches that would accompany the establishment of
European colonies in the Arab world.
Nevertheless, to
start a new general European massive movement, like the
Crusades, the leadership of a central figure was needed.
Pope Urban II was the only central figure at the time in
the entire West with an authority that transcended all
of Western Europe's national boundaries. On November 25,
1095, Pope Urban II delivered in Clermont, France, what
was perhaps the single most effective speech in Western
history - one that has influenced the West up to the
present time. Not only did the Pope appeal to the
Western masses through religious motives, but he also
used what came to be known as the typical Western
ideological argument in support of a colonialist and
imperialist policy that eventually led Europe in later
generations to brutally colonize the entire non-European
world. In this historic speech, Pope Urban II reminded
the Europeans that their lands were suffering from
widespread economic problems:
"For this land
which you inhabit, shut in on all sides by the seas and
surrounded by the mountain peaks, is too narrow for your
large population; nor does it abound in wealth, and it
furnishes scarcely food enough for its cultivators.
Hence it is that you murder and devour one another, that
you wage war, and that very many among you perish in
civil strife." [4]
The Pope then
quickly pointed out that the Arab land of Palestine to
which they would be going for their Crusade "floweth
with milk and honey ... like another paradise of
delights." [5] Pope Urban II then passionately exhorted
the faithful Westerners: "Set out on the road to the
Holy Sepulcher, take that land from the wicked people
and make it your own!" [6] After the Pope ended his
fiery speech, the entire large European crowd responded
jubilantly with a loud roar: "Dieu le veult!"
(God wills it!).
In fact, the
Western Crusaders were the first great wave of European
colonialism since the fall of the Roman Empire in 476.
The Crusades took the form of a series of brutal
military invasions in the name of "Christianity" to the
heart of Arab and Muslim lands in order to brutally
colonize Arab Palestine and kill its people. There were
at least nine major Western Crusades and many smaller
ones launched against the Arabs between 1095 and 1290:
The First (1095-1099); the Second (1147-1149); the Third
(1189-1192); the Fourth (1198-1204); the Children's
Crusade (1212); the Fifth (1217-1221); the Sixth
(1228-1229); the Seventh (1248-1254); the Eighth (1270);
and the Ninth (1290). Other ill-starred Western military
expeditions against the Arabs continued up to the 15th
century. Actually, Europe's hatred and fear of Arab and
Muslim power were so intense that the idea of the
Crusade persisted well into the 17th century, and the
conviction that war might be just and legitimate has
since become more deeply engraved in the conscience of
the West.
The Crusaders
came from all over Western Europe, but France was
somehow their main bulwark (from which Pope Urban II
himself came). A French monk described the First
Crusade, which was launched from France, as Gesta Dei
per Francos ("the Franks were presented as the
chosen instruments of God"!). [7] Not to be outdone by
the French in the service of God, however, many other
Europeans joined in such as English, Scottish, Welch,
Irish, Italians, Germans, Austrians, Spanish,
Portuguese, Normans, Belgians, Dutch, Scandinavians, and
Swiss. In this mass Crusader army, all classes and
segments of Western societies were represented. The
Crusaders included kings, knights, aristocrats, feudal
lords, priests, hermits, monks, dukes, military leaders,
soldiers, zealots, pilgrims, workers, peasants,
merchants, common people, and criminals. They also came
from both sexes and all ages (see "The Children's
Crusade" below).
The most
prominent of all the participating fanatics and zealots
among the Crusaders, however, was a strange Frenchman by
the name of Pierre L'Ermit ("Peter the Hermit") from the
city of Amiens. Pierre L'Ermit was one of history's most
bizarre characters, especially for a religious leader.
He looked like a madman; small and miserably thin;
walked barefooted; rode a jackass for transportation;
his wild unkempt hair tumbled over his neck and ears;
his unshaven wild beard came down to his waist; his eyes
rolled; his speech was torrential; and his dingy clothes
consisted of only a woolen smock and a light cloak which
also served him as a blanket at night. [8] Pierre
L'Ermit was a powerful speaker, though. His fiery
speeches hypnotized his Christian listeners who
nicknamed him "Kiokio" (or "little Peter"). His
followers used his jackass as an object of religious
veneration, plucking hairs from its tail to keep as
"holy relics"! [9] It was this strange, barefooted
Pierre L'Ermit who led the first column in the First
Crusade (known as the Peasants' Crusade) in 1096 against
the Arabs and Islam.
In order to
raise a large army to fight the Arabs and Islam, Pope
Urban II promised that all Crusaders would be exempted
from taxes; their debts would be forgiven; their sins
would be washed away; and their special place in
Paradise would be guaranteed. Consequently, the response
to his call was extraordinary. All in all about 160,000,
[10] heavily armed Europeans, an astounding figure for
that time, formed the armies of the First Crusade. It
seemed that the whole of Western Europe was marching
east. It was the first time that Western Europe had come
together for any cooperative act or cause since the fall
of the Roman Empire. Nothing like it has ever happened
in the history of the West. European unity was so clear
and so purposeful.
The Crusaders
came in a seemingly solid mass, some with all of their
belongings, to join in this mad holy war to destroy
Islam. Their objective was to kill Arabs and Turks whom
Pope Urban II described as "an accursed race, a race
utterly alienated from God", urging his followers to
"exterminate this vile race from our lands." [11] The
Crusades took place during the Western dark ages when
Europe was backward compared to the Arab/Muslim world
and to the Christian Byzantine Empire of East Europe.
Hence, the Crusaders' behavior during their vicious wars
reflected their cruelty and primitive barbarism. They
were extremely militant, and committed incredible mass
violence. They acted like modern-day violent American Ku
Klux Klan and other Western racist groups. They
committed, both in Europe and the Arab/Muslim world, the
worst conceivable horrible crimes and atrocities, not
only against thousands of innocent Muslims and Jews of
both sexes and of all ages, but also even against
Christians. Their vicious crimes - all of which will be
detailed shortly - against noncombatants and innocent
peoples included the destruction of properties;
pillaging; plundering; foraging; ravaging; stealing;
setting houses on fire; torturing; murdering; executing;
burning humans alive; raping women, including nuns; and
even roasting and eating (with a great deal of relish)
the human flesh of their victims and their children.
It must have
seemed that even Mother Nature (or God) was angry with
the Crusaders and was horrified by their sordid crimes.
Violent earthquakes devastated the Syrian Arab region at
various times during the Crusader’s 200-year presence in
the Arab world. Although the 1157 tremor was the most
spectacular, not even one single decade passed - during
which the Crusaders were pillaging and killing Arabs -
without some major cataclysm. [12] What follows is but a
brief account of the Crusaders' vicious 200-year bloody
assault on the Arabs and Islam.
III. Carnage in Turkey
Escorted by
Byzantine ships in the summer of 1096, the invading
Crusaders, led by the fanatic leader Pierre L'Ermit,
crossed the Bosporus into the land of Islam in Turkey.
After pillaging and plundering many Greek churches on
their way, the Crusaders were heard proudly shouting
that they had come to the land of Islam "to exterminate
the Muslims." [13] The Crusaders foraged the Turkish
countryside, plundered villages and farms and set them
on fire. They mercilessly massacred Muslim peasants and
burned their young children alive. [14] As pure racists,
the cruel Crusaders directed their violence towards any
dark-skinned peoples and those who simply wore different
clothes from them, regardless of their religions. Pierre
L'Ermit's peasant band even attacked non-Latin
Christians and slaughtered them in heavy numbers, hung
their babies on cooking spits, roasted them over open
fires, and ate their flesh. [15] Even Princess Anna
Comnena, the daughter of the Byzantine Emperor Alexius I
(who had the original idea of the Crusade but who came
to dislike the Crusaders like his daughter) reported how
they piled up the corpses of their victims to form a
high mountain. She also included a description of
Crusaders tearing off the limbs of children and roasting
others on fire for food. [16]
Nevertheless,
the Crusaders' very first encounter with a Muslim army
in 1096 in Nicaea (now modern Iznik in Turkey) ended in
a crushing military defeat for them and their leader,
Pierre L'Ermit, at the hands of Kilij Arsalan (the Red
Lion), the Turkish Sultan of that city. But this Muslim
victory was short-lived. The next year, in June 1097,
the Crusaders mounted a larger military force and, with
some help from the Byzantine army, inflicted a major
military defeat on the Muslim forces in Nicaea. This
time Arsalan was severely beaten at the Battle of
Dorylaeum, and the Muslim Turkish army was cut into
pieces. The Crusaders killed, pillaged, and took many
Muslims prisoners who were later sold into slavery. News
of the defeat of the Turkish Muslims spread like fire
into the Arab world and caused a great deal of panic and
pain. All Arabs and Muslims considered this first defeat
of the scientifically and culturally superior Muslims at
the hands of the backward Western Crusaders to be very
shameful. It was compared to the old defeat of the
highly advanced Roman Empire at the hands of the
northern European barbarians.
After their
victory in Turkey, the barbaric Crusaders moved south to
the Arab lands in their destination towards the Arab
province of Palestine. Every Arab village, town, and
city in their path was totally gripped by fear. Many
Arabs and Muslims fled for their lives, leaving behind
their homes and properties. The news of the Crusaders'
advances from town to town was closely followed as Arab
men and women in complete shock began to whisper to each
other and pray in fear.
IV. Bloodbath in Antioch
In February 1098
the Crusaders invaded Edessa (now the modern city of
Urfa in Turkey), a large Armenian community located
immediately north of Syria, known to the Arabs as
al-Ruha. The Crusaders ruthlessly massacred a large
number of Edessa's inhabitants and turned the city into
the first Latin Kingdom (European colony) in the Muslim
world under the leadership of Baldwin I of Boulogne,
France. Baldwin I was a knight notorious for his
brutality and complete lack of scruples. After he forced
the Christian Armenian prince and princess of Edessa to
abdicate, he proceeded to murder both of them even
though he had already accepted them as his "adopted
parents". [17]
Following their
easy invasion of Edessa. The Crusaders moved south to
destroy Arab Antioch, then the largest city in the Arab
region of Syria (now the modern city of Antakya in
Turkey). Antioch was well fortified and impossible to
penetrate. It had plenty of food and was well protected
against invasions and sieges. Its 12,000-meter-long
walls were very strong and indestructible. It had about
400 large towers, each of which was 60 feet high. More
than 50,000 heavily armed, bloodthirsty, fanatic
Crusaders stood at Antioch's gates and laid siege to it
for eight long and cold months during the rainy seasons
(from October 1097 to June 1098). Their long siege was
unsuccessful. Actually, while the Arabs inside Antioch
were enjoying plenty of food, the Crusaders stationed
outside it, faced severe hunger and starvation. As a
result, the Crusaders invaded, killed, ravaged, and
pillaged the surrounding Arab towns and villages, in and
around Aleppo, to steal livestock and crops. Frustrated
by their long unsuccessful siege of Antioch, the
Crusaders finally decided to frighten the city into
submission by gruesomely showering it with the mutilated
severed heads of murdered Arab Aleppens, catapulting
them over the city's strong walls like rain. [18] In
fact, the Crusaders' savagery found no boundary. One day
they caught a spy, killed him, roasted him on fire and
ate his flesh while proudly shouting that this would be
the fate of anyone who spied on them! [19]
However, the
siege of Arab Antioch suddenly came to a quick and
horrific end for its inhabitants. At 4 in the morning on
June 3, 1089, one of Antioch's gates was opened for
them. A Muslim traitor of Armenian origin by the name of
Fairuz, who was facing serious charges of black-market
trading and had been slapped with heavy fines by the
authorities in Antioch, decided to seek revenge. For a
large bribe of gold and land from the European invaders,
he allowed the Crusader leader Bohemond I (son of the
Prince of Taranto, Italy) to enter Antioch through one
of the five main gates that he was guarding. A swarm of
Christian European warriors fell upon the sleeping city
like uncontrollable madmen. In a short time the
Crusaders turned the entire city of Antioch into an
incredible scene of fire and blood. Wherever the
European Christians found Arab and Muslim women in the
city, "they ran their lances through their bellies."
[20] All the men, women, and children who tried to flee
in the heavy rain through muddy back-alleyways were
tracked down by the European knights and slaughtered on
the spot. As the day wounded down, cries of pleading,
fear, and agony from the dying, injured, and fleeing
Arabs and Muslims were gradually replaced by loud,
cheerful off-key singing of the drunken Crusaders who
were by then plundering the entire city of Antioch at
will. [21]
Such genocide by
the Europeans against the inhabitants of Arab Antioch
continued for an entire week as the city itself was
reeling under fire and smoke. All Muslims (both Arab and
non-Arab) and even native Christians (also Arab and
non-Arab alike) were tortured and killed by the
thousands, their houses looted and destroyed. By the end
of that dreadful week, scarcely a Muslim remained alive,
and the streets of Antioch were piled high with Arab and
Muslim corpses of both sexes and all ages. [22] Such
genocidal episodes punctuated the ruthless Crusaders
throughout their brutal occupation of Arab territories.
When an Arab
army from Mosul, Iraq arrived too late to save Antioch,
its leader Karbuqa and his troops were completely
stunned and paralyzed because of what they had seen at
Antioch. In fear and total shock, Karbuqa asked the
Crusaders for a truce, but without even responding to
his offer, the Crusaders charged at him and destroyed
his army, which quickly disintegrated "without a stroke
of sword or lance, without the firing of a single
arrow." [23] After this day of great shame for the Arabs
and Islam (especially with the Baghdad Arab caliphs
crippled and powerless in the face of the rapidly
growing power struggle between them and their Turkish
and Persian soldiers) there was no longer any Arab force
that could stop the vicious Crusaders from controlling
all of the vast Arab region of Syria. Thus, Arab Antioch
became the first Latin Kingdom or a European colony in
the Arab world (the second one in the Muslim world after
Edessa). Antioch fell under the ruthless leadership of
the butcher, Bohemond I.
V. Butchery and Cannibalism in Ma'arra
Following their
vicious capture of Antioch, the brutal Western Crusaders
moved on southward, raiding and pillaging town after
town on their way to Jerusalem. On their way south, the
unfortunate Arab Syrian city of Ma'arra was situated. In
December 1098, the city of Ma'arra, whose most important
son was the Arab genius philosopher/poet Abu al-Ala
al-Ma'arri (973-1057), experienced horrific cannibalism
against its Arab inhabitants at the hands of the
barbaric European Crusaders. Ironically, this
cannibalistic feast was predicted in a way by al-Ma'arri
who died only 41 years before it happened. Actually,
al-Ma'arri, who deeply influenced Dante, dared to attack
religious fanatics (Christians, Muslims, and Jews) and
even showed his irreligious audacity (in that early
eleventh-century time) by writing: "The inhabitants of
the earth are of two sorts: Those with brains, but no
religion, and those with religion, but no brains." [24]
The uncivilized
Western Christian Crusaders proved al-Ma'arri right by
quickly reducing his birthplace to a heap of ruins. A
peaceful Syrian agricultural city, Ma'arra had no army
or militia. Its economy was based only on grapes,
olives, and figs. Its unarmed Arab inhabitants
courageously resisted the crippling two-week Crusader
siege of their city by all means available to them,
including a desperate attempt by hurling packed beehives
on the European invaders.
Hopeless and
fearful of genocide similar to the one that had taken
place in Antioch a few months earlier, most of Ma'arra's
notables finally decided to accept the word of the
Crusaders' leader, Bohemond, who promised to spare the
lives of all the city's citizens if they would
surrender. But Bohemond, the ruthless ruler and butcher
of Antioch, proved once again that he was the vicious
Western animal that he really was. In the words of one
writer, on December 11, 1089, "The ... [Crusaders]
arrived at dawn. It was carnage. For three days they put
people to the sword, killing more than a hundred
thousand people and taking many prisoners." [25]
The Crusaders'
chronicler at the time, Radulph of Caen, not only
admitted this genocide, but also added, with pride, the
following horrifying words: "In Ma'arra our troops
boiled pagan adults in cooking pots; they impaled
children on spits and devoured them grilled." [26]
Another Christian Crusader chronicler, Albert of Aix,
who took part in the carnage of Ma'arra bragged, "Not
only did our troops not shrink from eating dead Turks
and Saracens [Arabs]; they also ate dogs!" [27]
Actually, even
before the massacre of Ma'arra took place, its Arab
inhabitants knew very well that there would be
cannibalism by the European Christians. The Arabs had
seen the fanatic Crusaders, the Tafurs, "roam through
the countryside openly proclaiming that they would chew
the flesh of ... [Arabs and Muslims] and gathering
around their nocturnal camp-fires to devour their prey."
[28] In fact, the barbaric Western Crusaders not only
enjoyed cooking and eating the flesh of Arabs and
Muslims, but they also found it even "better than spiced
peacock." [29]
After the bloody
nightmare of Ma'arra, the Western Crusaders moved on
southward towards Jerusalem, leaving nothing but
destruction and death in their wake. As a result of the
two great horrific massacres in Antioch and Ma'arra, the
Arabs began to look at the Westerners not only as beasts
and wild animals for their brutality and strength, but
also justifiably as savages and anthropophagi.
VI. Holocaust in Jerusalem
As the Western
Christian armies of doom moved southward, all Arabs and
Muslims, who lived in the villages and towns along the
road to the Arab city of Jerusalem, took extreme
precautions against the brutal Crusaders. The poorest
Arabs took refuge by hiding in nearby forests and
mountains, preferring to take their chances with hungry
lions, bears, hyenas, and wolves in the wilderness
rather than facing the invading barbaric cannibals from
the West.
Pope Urban II's
bloodthirsty warriors for Christ eventually reached
their goal, the city of Jerusalem. The bizarre Crusader
leader Pierre L'Ermit was appointed almoner of the
Christian army and continued his outrageous preaching,
this time at the Mount of Olives, just outside
Jerusalem. The Crusaders laid siege to Jerusalem for 40
days. Then in preparation for their assault on
Jerusalem, the soldiers of God fasted for three days,
confessed their "sins", and received communion. Next,
they marched barefooted around the walls of Jerusalem,
chanting psalms and carrying crosses and relics, in
abasement before the glory of the Lord. Suddenly, like
madmen, they hurled themselves against Jerusalem's walls
without carrying even a single ladder! From within
Jerusalem's high walls, the Arab garrisons could do
nothing but watch the wild Europeans in total horror and
astonishment. [30]
Crusader leader
Lord Tancred of Hauteville, France (Bohemond's nephew)
promised that if Jerusalem surrendered all Arab and
Muslim lifes in it would be spared and that the sanctity
of all Muslim religious places, especially al-Aqsa
Mosque, would be maintained. Accordingly, on Friday July
15, 1099, while the Muslims of Jerusalem were fearfully
praying in the mosques for their lives, the Arab
governor of Jerusalem surrendered without a fight to
Lord Tancred. But once again, just as his uncle had
broken his promises in Antioch and Ma'arra by butchering
most of their Muslims and Arabs, so did Tancred in
Jerusalem. Seized by a frenzy of vengeful blood lust,
the heavily-armed European Christian warriors stormed
Jerusalem like wild animals, spilling through the
streets of the holy city with swords in their hands and
indiscriminately butchering every man, woman, and child
they could find. They sacked mosques, broke open stores,
and plundered houses. Tens of thousands of noncombatants
(Arab and non-Arab whether Muslim, Jew, or even native
Christian) were beheaded, shot with arrows, thrown from
towers, tortured, or burned at the stake.
When their
killing finally stopped a week later on Friday, July 22,
not a single Arab or Muslim could be seen alive within
Jerusalem. Tens of thousands of Arabs and Muslims were
lying dead in pools of blood in front of their own
houses or stores and outside all of the holy city's
mosques, especially around al-Aqsa Mosque, which was
shamefully desecrated. It is estimated that more than
70,000 Arabs and Muslims were butchered in cold blood in
and around the great mosque of al-Aqsa alone. [31] The
Dome of the Rock next to al-Aqsa Mosque was converted to
a church by the Crusaders and was stripped of hundreds
of silver candelabra and dozens of gold ones. The bodies
of the dead Arabs and Muslims in the holy city were
slashed open in search of gold or silver coins they
might have swallowed. His "holiness" Pope Urban II had
decreed that any spoils of war were possessions the
faithful could keep. [32] At nightfall, still dripping
with the blood of their Arab victims, the Europeans
knelt at the "Holy Sepulcher" and folded their bloody
hands in prayer, "sobbing for excess of joy." [33]
Some lucky Arabs
and Muslims had taken advantage of the chaos to slip
away, escaping through gates battered down by the
Crusaders. In tears and in pain, the last Arab and
Muslim survivors in and around Jerusalem were forced by
the Crusaders to perform the most horrible tasks: to
drag the bodies of their own dead relatives, to heave
and dump them in enormous vacant and unmarked lots, and
finally to set them on fire. After performing these
horrible tasks, the Arabs were then beheaded, forcibly
drowned, or sold into slavery. [34] Religious historian
Ronald Bainton reported that before Jerusalem's murdered
Arabs and Muslims were buried en mass, their bodies were
mutilated and "a whole cargo of noses and thumps sliced
from [them]" were shipped to Europe as prized trophies!
[35]
One proud report
to Pope Urban II (who died two weeks later on July 29
without knowing that Jerusalem had been captured by
Christ's soldiers) read, "If you could hear how we
treated our enemies at Jerusalem ... our men rode
through the unclean blood of the Saracens [Arabs], which
came up to the knees of their horses." [36] One
eyewitness of the dreadful scene in Jerusalem not only
wrote that "piles of heads, hands, and feet were to be
seen in the streets of the city," but that the European
Christian murderers had "to pick their way over the
bodies of men and horses" all throughout the holy city.
[37] Describing the holocaust in Jerusalem, the
Archbishop of Tyre (modern Sur) wrote the following:
"… they laid
low, without distinction, every enemy encountered.
Everywhere was frightful carnage, everywhere lay heaps
of severed heads, so that soon it was impossible to pass
or to go from one place to another except over the
bodies of the slain. ... It was impossible to look upon
the vast number of the slain without horror; everywhere
lay fragments of human bodies, and the very ground was
covered with blood of the slain. It was not alone the
spectacle of headless bodies and mutilated limbs strewn
in all directions that roused the horror of all who
looked upon them. Still more dreadful was it to gaze
upon the victors themselves, dripping with blood from
head to foot, an ominous sight which brought terror to
all who met them..." [38]
The fate of the
Jews (Arab and non-Arab alike) of Jerusalem was no less
atrocious. During the first few hours of the carnage in
Jerusalem, the entire small Jewish community of the holy
city gathered in their own main synagogue to pray. The
Western blond knights barricaded the exits and stacked
all the bundles of wood they could find in a ring around
the synagogue. The Temple was then put to the torch.
Those Jews who managed to escape were massacred in the
neighboring alleyways. The rest were burned alive. [39]
The monuments of
saints and the tomb of Ibraheem (Abraham) were also
completely destroyed by the Crusaders. One eyewitness
wrote that at the Temple of Solomon, where about 10,000
Jews were slaughtered, "men rode in blood up to their
knees and bridle reins." [40] In writing about the
mutilated Jewish corpses that covered the Temple area,
the priest Raymond of Aguilers joyfully quoted Psalm
118: "This is the day the Lord has made. Let us rejoice
and be glad in it." [41]
Because of their
dark ages mentality, racism, brutality, and deep hatred
for any alien culture, the Crusaders did not even spare
their coreligionists in the Arab world from their
bloodbaths as many native Christians were murdered. The
Crusaders proceeded to expel from the Church of the
"Holy Sepulcher" all the priests of the Orthodox and
Monophysite Oriental rites - Arabs, Greeks, Armenians,
Georgians, and Copts - who had formerly worked together
peacefully for centuries under Arab/Muslim rule in
Jerusalem to officiate Christian religious ceremonies.
Completely dumfounded and deeply indignant at this cruel
treatment, the local Orthodox Christian priests refused
to tell the European invaders where they had hidden the
True Cross on which Jesus died. Totally frustrated, the
European occupiers arrested the Orthodox priests,
tortured them and forced them to reveal its secret
location. In addition, Arab and other non-Latin
Christians lost their churches and properties, and were
displaced from their patriarchates and bishoprics. Even
the Arab Maronite Christians (who were in communion with
Rome) were contemptuously treated as second-class
citizens in their own native Arab land by these invading
Westerners. [42] Also, in addition to the "heretic"
Muslims and Jews, the Crusaders banned the Arab Coptic
Christians of Egypt from going to Jerusalem to conduct
their pilgrimage.
For the official
celebration of murdering tens of thousands of innocent
Palestinian Muslims, Jews, and Christians in cold blood,
and for the brutal torture and displacement of local
Christians, the victorious European faithful held
several glorious Christian religious processions
conducted in the streets of Jerusalem by none other than
that firebrand preacher, Pierre L'Ermit. Thus Arab
Jerusalem became the second European colony in the Arab
world (a Latin Kingdom like Arab Antioch) ruled by the
bloodthirsty Godfrey (Duke of Lower Lorraine, Germany)
from the French City of Bouillon (now located in
southern Belgium). Godfrey made his official residence
(of all places) in the sacred Muslim al-Aqsa Mosque of
Jerusalem. On the other hand, the perfidious Lord
Tancred became the proud Prince of Galilee.
Although the
Arabs and Muslims knew very well that they were
scientifically and culturally far superior to the
Western hordes in every area of science and art, they
still feared the European invaders and had nothing but
deep hatred and profound contempt for them. One Arab
chronicler at the time, Usamah Ibn Munqidh, who had
become the leading Damascene specialist on the
Crusaders, recorded his observations about the Western
Christian fanatic enemies as follows:
"Their
soldiers are of mighty courage and in the hour of combat
do not think of flight but prefer death. But you shall
see none more filthy [sic] than they. They do not
cleanse or bathe themselves more than once or twice a
year, and then in cold water, and they do not wash their
garments from the time they put them on till they fall
to pieces. They are a people of treachery and mean
character." [43]
A few days after
the holocaust in Jerusalem, the first Arab Palestinian
refugees arrived in Damascus. Although they were sick in
their hearts at having been forced to run for their
lives and having to abandon their homes and properties
in Palestine - the same way their descendants did in
1948 when the Western Zionists brutally settle-colonized
Palestine - they were determined never to return to
Palestine until all the European invaders had departed
from it forever. They resolved then to awaken the
conscience of their Arab and Muslim brothers all over
the land of Islam to rise in an Islamic "holy war" or
Jihad to expel the Western invaders.
The Arab defense
against the savage Western onslaught, however, was a
dismal failure from the beginning. The Arabs were, as
they are now, divided and in conflict with each other.
The Abbasid State was fragmented and had deteriorated
into a commonwealth of semiautonomous quarrelsome states
governed by Arab or Turkish military commanders. The
Abbasid capital city of Baghdad was totally paralyzed,
and the weak Arab Abbasid Caliph, al-Mustazhir, was
crippled by the power struggle among Arabs, Persians,
and Turks.
VII. Slaughters in Other Arab Cities and Towns
Despite such
Arab division and quarrels, an army was raised from the
Arab region of Egypt to try to expel the European
invaders from the Arab region of Palestine. While the
Western savage Crusaders were looting Jerusalem and
completing their massacres by killing the last few
hidden Arab survivors in the holy city, the Egyptian
army slowly reached Palestine in August 1099, 20 days
after the holocaust in Jerusalem. Aware of its arrival,
however, the Crusaders met the Egyptian army near the
Palestinian port city of Ascalon where it was camping
and completely annihilated it. "Neither foot-soldier,
nor volunteers, nor the people of the city [Ascalon]
were spared in the killing. About ten thousand souls
perished, and the camp was sacked." [44]
Several days
after this last Arab defeat and humiliation, a group of
Arab refugees led by the Judge of Damascus, Abu Sa'ad
al-Harawi, reached Baghdad to plead to the politically
crippled Arab Abbasid Caliph, al-Mustazhir, for an
Arab/Muslim military defense against the Crusaders. In
the Great Mosque of Baghdad, on Friday August 19, 1099,
during the Muslim holy month of Ramadan, al-Harawi
denounced the disgraceful inaction by Muslim leaders and
passionately appealed for a Jihad against the savage
European invasion. His fiery speech made the Muslim
congregation weep. However, despite the fact that
al-Harawi carried his appeal as far away as the great
corridors of power in Baghdad, his efforts amounted to
naught; Baghdad was indeed paralyzed.
Hence, the cruel
Western Crusaders felt totally free to continue
pillaging, ravaging, and killing Arabs and Muslims with
impunity. In 1101 the soldiers of Christ committed yet
another major gory massacre against the Arabs in the
Palestinian seaport city of Caesarea. When the Crusaders
invaded this quiet city, their troops were given
permission to sack it as they pleased. All the
Palestinian inhabitants of the city were brought in and
murdered in cold blood in the city's great mosque. [45]
Also, the following year, in a raging battle near
Tripoli in April 1102, the Crusaders, under the
leadership of the brute Raymond of Saint-Gilles (Count
of Toulouse, France), relentlessly butchered 7,000
Tripolitanian Arabs. [46]
Even when a
golden opportunity was presented to them, the Arabs let
it slip by. For example, in May 1102 an Egyptian army
took the Crusaders army by surprise in the city of
Ramlah, near the port of Jaffa in Palestine. While most
of his knights were killed or captured, the king of
Jerusalem himself, Baldwin I, barely avoided capture by
hiding, while lying flat on his stomach, among the
reeds. That day the Egyptian army could have marched
unopposed to free Jerusalem from the Europeans, but due
to the reluctance and indecisiveness of its leaders, the
chance was lost. And, although the Egyptians thereafter
kept sending a fresh army year after year to free
Jerusalem, they never had the same golden opportunity
again. [47] As a result, the Arabs paid dearly both in
lives and properties, as they began to lose quickly city
after city to the Crusaders.
In 1104, the
Crusaders brutally captured three important Arab cities:
Jaffa, Haifa, and Acre. Also, after bravely resisting
their severe 2000-day siege, Tripoli was invaded and
destroyed in July 1109 by the brutal Crusaders who
massacred scores of its noncombatant Arabs in cold
blood. Tripoli was a magnificent bustling seaport, the
jewel of the Arab east, known for its splendid living
and beautiful fields of fruits, carobs, olives, and
sugarcane. It had talented goldsmiths, brave seamen,
scholars, learned judges, and glorious libraries. The
uncultured Genoese sailors completely demolished the
city's Banu Ammar library, the finest in the Muslim
world, [48] which was known as Dar al-Ilm or
"House of Knowledge". The Crusaders destroyed all of its
100,000 volumes so that Arab "impious" books would not
be read by anyone. Most of Tripoli's citizens were sold
into slavery, the rest were despoiled of their
properties and stripped of their personal belongings as
they were being expelled from the city. Most expelled
Tripolitanians found refuge in the nearby Arab city of
Tyre. Following the examples of Antioch and Jerusalem,
Tripoli became the third European colony in the Arab
world, divided into three equal parts. One third came
under the colonization of the Genoese, and the other two
thirds fell under the brutal control of the cruel son of
Raymond of Saint-Gilles.
The following
year, in May 1110, the Crusaders selected Beirut as
their next target where they committed yet another
horrible massacre against scores of innocent Arabs. [49]
Then, the following December, they attacked the peaceful
seaport of Sayda (the ancient Phoenician city of Sidon),
where they cruelly forced all of its Arab inhabitants
into a mass exodus to Tyre and Damascus. Thus, in a
short period of time, the European invaders brutally
captured six of the most renowned Arab cities - Jaffa,
Haifa, Acre, Tripoli, Beirut, and Sayda - massacred
and/or deported their inhabitants, and desecrated their
mosques. These dreadful events sent a chill down the
spine of the entire Arab nation as Arab masses
throughout the entire Arab world began to fear seriously
that Tyre, Aleppo, Mosul, Damascus, Cairo, Baghdad, or
even Makkah (“Mecca”) itself might be the next target
for the European soldiers of God.
As a result of
this widespread fear, the Aleppo Judge, Abdulfadhel Ibn
al-Khashab, organized a large demonstration in the
Abbasid capital of Baghdad in February 1111 against the
inept Abbasid Caliph al-Mustazhir, demanded an immediate
Arab military response, and emotionally called for an
Islamic Jihad to expel the Crusaders. But, like
his predecessor, al-Harawi 12 years earlier, Ibn
al-Khashab's efforts amounted to very little. The
Baghdad riots, however, ignited a strong angry feeling
all over the Arab world among Arab masses that
considered some of their leaders to be shamefully
incompetent while some others to be outright traitors.
In fact, some
Arab and Turkish governors committed acts of high
treason, for their personal gains, by collaborating with
the Crusaders in the same fashion as Saudi Arabia's
House of Saud and Kuwait's House of Sabah have currently
collaborated with the imperialist West. For example,
after the Baghdad riots, the citizens of Arab Ascalon
rose in July 1111 in a violent revolt against their
treasonous and cowardly leader, Shams al-Khalifa, who
had offered a tribute of 7,000 dinars to the
brutal European colonialist Baldwin I of Jerusalem. In
return, Baldwin I sent al-Khalifa 300 of his soldiers to
protect him against possible insurrection. However, the
Palestinian Arab masses became completely outraged and a
group of them assassinated al-Khalifa as he was leaving
his residence; the 300 Crusader soldiers were also
massacred. [50]
Nevertheless,
the Crusaders continued to occupy new Arab cities at
will. For although the ruler of Aleppo, Najm ad-Din
Ilghazi, crushed the Crusaders' army at Antioch in June
1119 on the Syrian plain of Sarmada and killed their new
arrogant leader Sir Roger (the son of Prince Richard of
Salerno, Italy), who had imposed a tax on every Muslim
pilgrim leaving Antioch to Makkah, the overall power of
the Crusaders was not affected. The Sarmada defeat,
however, like the 1104 Harran defeat before it in
Turkey, was nothing more than a temporary setback for
the Western soldiers of God. In fact, the Europeans
brutally captured Tyre in 1124 and thus completed their
total control, with the exception of Ascalon, of the
entire Arab Eastern coast of the Mediterranean.
VIII. The Arab Victory over the Western Crusaders
Arab victory
over the Westerners was painful and slow in coming. The
first major turning point for the Arabs came in 1144 at
the hands of the governor of Mosul, in the Arab region
of Iraq, Imad ad-Din Zangi. Zangi, who owed nominal
allegiance to the Abbasid Caliph of Baghdad, liberated
Edessa and completely destroyed this first of four
Crusader colonies in the Muslim world. Zangi's victory
was widely celebrated across the entire Muslim world as
Arabs and Muslims began to strongly feel that all the
European invaders would soon be expelled from their
three other colonies of Jerusalem, Antioch, and Tripoli,
as well as from the rest the Arab world.
However, upon
receiving the news of Edessa's fall, Pope Eugenius III
urgently called for the Second Crusade (1147-1149)
against the Arabs in order to recapture Edessa. In an
immediate response to his call, powerful European armies
were gallantly organized. The Second Crusade was led by
the Emperor Conard III of Germany and King Louis VII of
France. Although this time heads of European states were
personally involved in the military invasion of the Arab
world, the Second Crusade achieved nothing, failed to
retake Edessa, and ended in a humiliating defeat for the
Europeans near Damascus. In the spring of 1148, the
deeply pious and ascetic Nur ad-Din (Zangi's son)
destroyed the army of the Second Crusade. Upon hearing
the news of Nur ad-Din's brilliant military victory over
the French King and the German Emperor, the entire Arab
world was immediately seized by a sense of elation.
Undaunted by
this defeat, however, the occupying Crusaders of the
Arab lands continued their murderous campaigns against
Arabs and non-Arabs (Muslim, Christian and Jewish) in
the Eastern Mediterranean. For example, in the spring of
1156 the Crusader French Knight, Reynald of Chatillon
(prince of Antioch: 1153-1160) - a brutal, arrogant,
cynical, and contemptible person who would come to
symbolize to all Arabs and Muslims everything evil about
the West - viciously invaded the Christian non-Arab
island of Cyprus. He and his army of God ravaged all of
the island's cultivated fields, slaughtered all of the
livestock, pillaged all of the churches and convents,
burned and demolished buildings, raped women,
slaughtered old men and children, beheaded poor men,
took rich men as hostages, and cut off the noses of all
Greek Christian priests. [51] Similar examples of these
murderous campaigns took place in October 1168 when the
Westerners committed a major gory operation against the
Arabs in Bilbays, Egypt. The European Christian
Crusaders systematically massacred scores of innocent
Arabs (both Muslims and Coptic Christians) including
men, women and children without the slightest
provocation. [52]
To the
Crusaders' misfortune, however, in 1169, the following
year, a young military genius gained control of Egypt at
the tender age of 31. His name was Salah ad-Din
al-Ayyobi (known in the West as Saladin), a man of
enormous courage and character. Salah ad-Din was born in
the city of Tikrit, Iraq, in which the Iraqi President
Saddam Hussein was also born. Not knowing who was Salah
ad-Din and what he would come to represent, the soldiers
of Christ continued their bloody operations against the
Arabs. The utterly detestable Reynald of Chatillon
violated the 1180 truce between the Arabs and the
Crusaders by plundering a Muslim caravan in its way to
Makkah in the summer of 1181. He then launched five
galleys on the Red Sea with which he blockaded the Arab
port of Elath (Eilat); harassed Arab shipping; raided
other Arab seaports including the two Hejazi seaports of
Yanbuh (the port serving the city of Madinah) and Rabigh
near Jeddah; and even threatened the city of Makkah
itself.
In 1182, to the
horror of all Islam, the Crusaders sank a crowded Muslim
pilgrim ship, drowning all aboard. [53] Later, in 1186,
the French butcher of Cyprus, Reynald of Chatillon, who
had made it his pattern to pillage and massacre Arabs
without restraint, broke yet another truce with Salah
ad-Din by plundering an Arab caravan in which a sister
of Salah ad-Din was traveling. This French animal felt
bound by no truce or agreement; he once cynically
explained, "What was the value of an oath sworn to
infidels?” [54] Again, in 1187, this French murderer
raided yet another large caravan of Arab pilgrims and
merchants who were peacefully making their way to
Makkah. Reynald and his men mercilessly massacred all
the armed Arab men and led the rest of the caravan
troops into captivity. When some of the captured Arabs
reminded him of the truce he had signed with Salah
ad-Din, Reynald defiantly answered them, "Let your
Muhammad come and deliver you!" When Salah ad-Din heard
his words, he swore by the holy Qur'an that he would
kill Reynald with his own hands. [55]
In fact, Salah
ad-Din - who extended his control from Egypt to the
other Arab provinces of Syria, northern Iraq, Barqah (in
the Arab region of Libya), the Hejaz, and Yemen - was
actually waiting for just such a provocation from the
European invaders in order to wage a war against them.
War broke out between the Arabs and the Westerners in
the summer of 1187 with an immediate blow to the
invading Crusaders. On July 4, 1187, Salah ad-Din's
military genius came into play when he trapped and
destroyed an exhausted and thirst-crazed army of
Crusaders in the battle of Hittin, near Lake Tiberias in
northern Palestine. The Europeans suffered heavy losses;
the 20,000 who survived fell into captivity, including
the French king of Jerusalem, Guy of Lusignan. Although
Salah ad-Din displayed his famous magnanimity and spared
the lives of the European King of Jerusalem and most of
the Western prisoners (most of whom were later set free,
including the ones who could not pay their war ransoms),
he fulfilled his pledge to God against Reynald of
Chatillon. Salah ad-Din personally killed this Frenchman
by cutting off his head with the sword. Dragging
Reynald's dead body by its feet to the captive French
king, who began to tremble of fear for his own life,
Salah ad-Din said to him, "This man was killed only
because of his maleficence and his perfidy." [56]
So great were
the Westerners' losses that the Arabs were able to
liberate quickly the Crusaders’ entire Kingdom of
Jerusalem, with the exception of Tyre. The Arab cities
of Acre, Toron, Beirut, Jubayl (Byblos), Sayda,
Nazareth, Caesarea, Nabulus, Jaffa, Haifa, Ascalon, and
Jerusalem were liberated in a few months. After 88 years
of European colonization, Jerusalem was back finally
under Arab control. As the entire Muslim world was
celebrating, Salah ad-Din entered Jerusalem as a
liberating hero on Friday October 2, 1187 (Rajab 27, 583
in the Islamic Calendar), the very same day on which
Muslims annually celebrate Prophet Mohammad's nocturnal
journey to Heaven via Jerusalem.
In stark
contrast to the holy city's conquest nine decades
earlier by the Europeans who had perfidiously and
barbarically slaughtered its inhabitants, the Arab
liberation of Jerusalem was marked neither by a massacre
nor by a plunder, but by the civilized and courteous
behavior of Salah ad-Din and his troops. In fact, Salah
ad-Din not only strengthened the guard at the Christian
places of worship to protect them from harm by unruly
Muslims, but he also announced that all unarmed
Westerners were welcome to come to Jerusalem on
pilgrimage whenever they liked. Local Arab and non-Arab
Christians welcomed Salah ad-Din in Jerusalem as a
liberator. Arab Jews as well as non-Arab Jews were also
allowed to resettle in Jerusalem. The only Arab lands
left in the hands of the Western invaders were the city
of Tyre as well as the two European colonies/kingdoms of
Tripoli and Antioch.
IX. The Incredible Massacre in Acre
Upon hearing the
news that the Arabs had recaptured Jerusalem, Pope
Gregory VIII went into a fit. Highly outraged, he
immediately called for the Third Crusade (1189-1192) to
capture Jerusalem and punish the Arabs. This time, the
West responded with the largest Crusader army to date
led by the greatest three monarchs in all of Europe:
Frederick Barbarossa, king of Germany and "Holy" Roman
emperor; Richard I, the so-called "Lion-Heart", king of
England; and Philip II Augustus, king of France. Hence,
the Third Crusade is dubbed the "Kings' Crusade."
However, before
achieving anything, the Third Crusade suffered a major
setback on June 10, 1190, when Frederick Barbarossa
suddenly died. The Holy Roman emperor died not by Salah
ad-Din's sword, but rather by drowning while swimming in
a shallow stream, the Saleph River, at the foot of the
Taurus Mountains in Turkey. As a result, the German
Crusader army was dispersed. Nonetheless, the English
and French kings proceeded with their troops and took
Acre in 1191 after a very gruesome battle with the
Arabs. The siege and battle of Acre, which took two
years, was the most protracted and desperate bloody
episode in the Arab world. Twenty-four thousand Arab
fighters died in that battle and about 6,000 others were
wounded. [57]
After the fall
of Acre, King Richard proceeded to loot a large amount
of gold and other fortunes from its Arab inhabitants.
Then, contrary to his promises to spare the lives of the
surviving Arabs in Acre, under the surrender terms he
had accepted, the English King issued orders to the
Anglo-French troops on August 20, 1191 that led to one
of the most cowardly and atrocious massacres the
Crusaders ever committed during their 200-year bloodbath
in the Arab world. On that very hot and humid day in
August, the entire surviving population of Acre, 2,700
Arabs - men, children, and women with babies clinging to
them - were chained and roped to prevent their escape
and restrict their movement. Totally frightened and
deeply confused, the weeping and praying Arabs were then
driven like animals with whips and clubs to the top of a
low hill called Ayyadieh to meet their awful fate. One
author describes what happened next to these 2,700 Arabs
as follows:
"Richard's men
began to carry out his orders to kill them all. Swords,
spears, knives, axes all flashed in the sun as they rose
and fell. This time the children were not saved for the
slave market, but were butchered with their fathers and
mothers. Even babies in their mother’s arms felt the
knives of the blood-drenched Christians ... The killing
completed, Richard's army started back to the city,
while on the top of the hill a few loot-crazed butchers
lurched from one body to another with their bloody
knives, hastily disemboweling corpses to recover any
gold pieces that might have been swallowed for
concealment ... Nor were the prisoners and their
families the only deaths he [king Richard I] was
responsible for that day. As news of the slaughter
spread throughout Saladin's empire, Christian prisoners
everywhere were tortured and murdered in reprisal for
the infamy..." [58]
After defeating
a small battalion of Salah ad-Din's army at the Arab
Palestinian village of Arsouf, fifteen miles from Jaffa,
the English king celebrated his looting and murdering of
thousands of innocent Arabs in cold blood by proudly
accepting and then arrogantly bestowing upon himself the
courageous nickname the "Lion-Heart". To the English, he
may be the "Lion-Heart", and to the French he may be "Le
Coeur de Lion", but to all Arabs and Muslims King
Richard I of England has always been viewed as a
cowardly butcher, a perfidious criminal, and a murderous
thug.
Nevertheless,
frustrated by their inability to fulfill the Third
Crusade's main goal, the capture of Jerusalem from Salah
ad-Din, the two European monarchs of England and France
returned as failures to their respective countries.
Before leaving for Europe, however, the English king
signed a peace treaty in 1192 with Salah ad-Din that
limited the European invaders to Tyre and a narrow
coastal strip from Jaffa to Acre. The treaty also gave
unarmed European pilgrims the right to visit Jerusalem.
On the other hand, Salah ad-Din was so emotionally
wounded by the European perfidious massacre in Acre that
he shed many painful tears and spent long sleepless
nights in total agony. He died in 1193 in Damascus with
a broken heart at the young age of 55, blaming himself
for the whole tragedy.
X. The Last Ten Crusades and Their Atrocities
Still full of
hatred towards Muslims and Arabs, especially after the
Third Crusade failed to take Jerusalem from the Arabs,
Pope Innocent III urgently called for the Fourth Crusade
(1198-1204) to be directed this time at Egypt, the most
powerful Arab region. However, the Fourth Crusade was
even a bigger failure than the Third. It never even
reached the Arab world as planned. The wily Doge of
Venice and the rich Venetian merchants who controlled
the finances of the Fourth Crusading army diverted it to
its original and natural commercial ends by attacking
and seizing the rival Christian Dalmatian Seaport City
of Zara (now modern Zadar in Croatia). In November 1202,
the unrestrained soldiers of God completely pillaged and
destroyed Zara. Then in 1204, for good measures, they
went and sacked Constantinople itself, the glorious
Byzantine capital of the Christian Eastern Roman Empire
whose emperor Alexius I, ironically, was responsible for
the original idea of a Western Crusade against the Arabs
and Islam. The Crusaders and Venetian merchants then
established the Latin Empire of Constantinople, which
lasted until 1261. While brutally conquering the capital
city of their fellow European Christians in East Europe
"to the honor of God, the Pope and the empire", the
Crusaders were permitted to rampage and steal as they
pleased for three days. They broke into the city's main
Cathedral of Hagia Sophia, shattered the large silver
crosses, ripped away the hangings, and stole many
valuables. They even raped nuns and put a prostitute on
the Patriarch's throne to sing a dirty French song.
Finally, they drank the "holy" altar wine out of
chalices, and threw all the Christian ikons and bibles
down on the floor to be trampled under their feet. [59]
Eight years
later, in 1212, saw the most bizarre and pathetic
Children's Crusade in which 100,000 Western European
children took part [60]. One third of these European
children, composed mostly of French and German
youngsters, was eventually lost or sold into slavery and
prostitution by none other than their own Western fellow
Christians. A 12-year old French farm boy named Stephen
of Cloyes insisted that Christ had asked him to organize
a children's crusade to liberate Jerusalem from the
Arabs. Tens of thousands of destitute French youngsters,
who endured hardships of hunger and diseases, answered
Stephen's call and marched with him south to the French
seaport city of Marseille where they expected God to
part the waters of the Mediterranean for them so that
they could walk dry-shod all the way to Palestine.
Instead, their French slave-trader compatriots from
Marseille lured them into ships and sold them into
slavery to the Arabs. The same year another absurd and
ridiculous crusade against the Arabs, composed this time
of tens of thousands of helpless German children, was
launched. Organized by the German youngster Nicholas of
Cologne, the second Children's Crusade got no further
than Italy. Many of the German youngsters suffered a
great deal from want and exhaustion, and many of the
young girls ended up in Roman brothels.
Nevertheless,
because the Fourth Crusade attacked the Christian
Byzantine Empire instead of its intended target, Egypt,
Pope Innocent III called for the Fifth Crusade
(1217-1221) to attack this vital Arab region of Egypt.
Chiefly manned by French and German Crusaders, the Fifth
Crusade failed to destroy Egypt. However, it managed to
capture Damietta, near the Nile River, where the
Crusaders committed various atrocities in 1218-19. One
of their most notorious crimes was the drowning of
almost 1,500 innocent Arabs and Muslims by sinking their
ship near Damietta. [61] And, once again, the European
Christian Crusaders treated the local Arab Christians
with total contempt. They regarded the Egyptian Copts
(Monophysite Christians) as heretic as Muslims.
Fortunately for the Arabs, however, the Egyptian Sultan,
al-Malik al-Kamil, Salah ad-Din's nephew, managed to
beat the Fifth Crusade in 1221 and force the European
soldiers of God out of Egypt.
Nonetheless,
seven years after the Fifth Crusade was repelled from
Egypt, the Sixth Crusade (1228-1229) was launched.
Strangely this new Crusade was bloodless. It was
launched as a diplomatic Crusade by the most powerful
Western monarch, Frederick II, King of Germany and
Sicily, who was under excommunication by Pope Gregory
IX. Skeptical of all religions, including Christianity,
Frederick II openly flouted papal authority. In 1229,
Frederick II negotiated a very strange and special
treaty with Sultan al-Kamil of Egypt by which he
peacefully obtained European control of Jerusalem,
Bethlehem, and Nazareth for ten years.
Although
Frederick II enjoyed a positive image in the Arab world
because he spoke and wrote good Arabic; had a great
admiration for Arab civilization; was surrounded by an
entourage of Arab and Muslim advisors; and had nothing
but contempt for the barbarous West, especially for the
Pope, his unusual treaty with al-Kamil to take control
of Jerusalem still aroused a storm of indignation
throughout the Arab world. When al-Kamil's extremely
generous treaty with Frederick II expired in 1239, the
Arabs recovered Jerusalem in 1244 and permanently ended
the Crusaders' occupation of the city. However,
al-Kamil's treaty with Frederick II has been compared by
many Arab and Muslim scholars not only with the 1979
sell-out of Camp David Treaty, signed by Egypt's Anwar
as-Sadat and Israel's Menachem Begin, but also with the
more recent so-called "peace process" of the 1990s that
Yasser Arafat signed with Israel.
Nevertheless,
violent and militant Western crusading efforts against
the Arabs continued. The French King Louis IX gallantly
led the Seventh Crusade (1248-1254) against Egypt.
However, like the Fifth Crusade thirty years earlier,
the Seventh Crusade failed in its mission miserably.
Soon after he captured Damietta where he offended the
Egyptian Christian Copts by appointing a Catholic
prelate as Patriarch of their city, the Egyptians
soundly defeated King Louis IX. The French King was also
deeply humiliated when he was personally captured as a
prisoner. He was not released until he paid a high
ransom. The Egyptians finally allowed him to rejoin his
wife in the Western-occupied Arab city of Acre.
Totally
exhausted by the Crusades' continuing devastating wars
and destruction for over 150 years, the Arab world was
not ready or able to defend itself against a new and
dangerous enemy, the Mongol hordes from the East. In
1258, the Mongols, under their vicious leader Hulagu (or
the George W. Bush of his day), completely destroyed
Baghdad and effectively ended Arab civilization. The
Mongols pillaged Baghdad; murdered one million Muslims
in it [62]; destroyed its palaces and mosques; burned
its libraries and schools; dumped Arab scientific and
other treasure books in the Tigris River; destroyed the
Iraqi irrigation canal systems; and executed the last
Abbasid Caliph and all of his Arab ruling family.
Although the Arab world has never completely recovered
from this Mongols' crushing defeat, Muslim civilization
itself continued for centuries thereafter under the
powerful leadership of the Ottoman Turks.
However, in
1260, two years after the destruction of the Abbasid
State, a brilliant Arabic-speaking Turkish leader from
Egypt by the name of az-Zahir Baybars severely crushed
the Mongol forces at Ayn Jalut, near Nazareth, in
Palestine and ended their brief destructive presence in
the Arab world. Baybars then dealt very harshly with the
Western Crusaders, who collaborated with the ruthless
Mongols, and mercilessly killed them. He recovered from
the Crusaders several Arab cities: Arsouf in 1265;
Atlit, Haifa and Safed in 1266; and Jaffa and Antioch
(their prized-colony) in 1268.
Nevertheless,
undaunted by either his earlier humiliating defeat and
captivity in Egypt during the Seventh Crusade or by
Baybars' stunning military victories both against the
invading Mongols and Crusaders, King Louis IX of France
tried once again to beat the Arabs in 1270 by launching
the Eighth Crusade. This stubborn French monarch, who
was full of hate for the Arabs and Islam, decided this
time to "cut" the Arab world in half by invading
Tunisia. Instead, he cut his own life short when he died
of a virus near Tunis on August 25, 1270. His majesty's
body was then taken back to Paris where he was
ceremoniously buried as a "saint".
Another major
military defeat for the Crusaders in the Arab world took
place in 1271 when the great Baybars of Egypt captured
their most formidable fortress in Syria, Hisn
al-Akrad (known in French as Crak des Chevaliers),
which not even the powerful Salah ad-Din had been able
to conquer. This immense Crusaders fortress is still in
existence today dominating the Syrian plains of Bukaya,
reminding all Arabs of the past Western Christian
terrorism, and making them draw parallels to the present
Israeli and American brutal policies in Arab lands.
In 1289 the
Crusaders also suffered another major military defeat
when the new Egyptian ruler, Sultan al-Mansur Qalawun,
thrilled the entire Muslim world by capturing Tripoli,
the Crusaders' last kingdom/colony in the Arab world.
After this defeat, the European invaders were left with
only one Arab city under their control, the port-city of
Acre, now under the brutal rule of King Henry of France.
These military
defeats suffered by the Crusaders in the Arab world made
Pope Nicholas IV panic and led him in the summer of 1290
to respond to King Henry's appeal for fresh
reinforcements. Launched under the Pope’s order, the
Ninth Crusade was composed of a large fleet full of
European Christian chauvinists. It sailed from Italy
directly to the Western-occupied Arab city of Acre. Once
in Acre, the Western soldiers of God began to drink
heavily. They then rushed drunkenly through its streets,
indiscriminately attacking and killing Arab merchants,
innocent bystanders, and any man wearing a beard
regardless of his religion. Many Arab and non-Arab
Christians were murdered in cold blood. These crimes and
atrocities made the Egyptian leader Qalawun extremely
angry. He swore by the holy Qur'an that he would not lay
down his arms until he drove all of the European
invaders out of the entire Arab world and into the
Mediterranean Sea. [63] However, it was only after
Qalawun's death in 1290 that his own son, Sultan
al-Ashraf Khalil, who in 1291liberated Acre (the last
Western hold in the Arab world), fulfilled his wish.
While the French King Henry and most other European
notables quickly ran away from Acre to hide in Cyprus,
all other Westerners in the city were captured and
mercilessly killed by Khalil's troops. The liberation of
Acre took place exactly 100 years, almost to the day,
after the Europeans had brutally re-captured it from the
Arabs in 1191 and massacred all its inhabitants under
the orders of King Richard I of England. Sultan Khalil
of Egypt was to go down in history as the ruler who
finally expelled the last of the West Europeans by
putting an end to two centuries of their terrorism and
cruel colonization in the Arab world. While all Arabs
were celebrating their last victory over the Crusaders,
they were also at the same time praying and asking God
to grant that the barbarian terrorist Westerners never
set foot again in the Arab world.
The Arab
prayer was answered, but only for a few decades.
Seventy-four years after their expulsion from Acre, the
stubborn Westerners organized yet another Crusade in
1365 under the command of King Peter of Cyprus.
Considered to be the last of the great international
Crusades, this Tenth Crusade was launched against the
mostly Christian Arab City of Alexandria. It was yet
another totally pointless brutal invasion by the West in
which thousands of Arab Christians, Muslims, and Jews
were massacred in cold blood. Even the Latin traders had
their stores and houses looted and destroyed by King
Peter's Crusaders. [64] However, the Tenth Crusade,
which was quickly repelled by the Arabs, ended with the
assassination of King Peter himself.
Nevertheless, in
1395 when the Turkish Muslim army was laying siege on
Constantinople, the Byzantine emperor Manuel II
Palaeologus appealed to the rulers of Europe for help.
Responding to his call, the "Holy" Roman Emperor/King
Sigismund of Hungary organized in July 1396 the Eleventh
Crusade against Islam and the Arabs. The objective of
the Eleventh Crusade was not only to evict the Muslim
Turks from the Balkans, but also to march into Syria and
to "liberate" Jerusalem from the Arabs. Led by Sigismund
in September 1396, this Crusade was also composed of
Western knights from the Balkans, France, Burgundy,
Germany, England, and the Netherlands. However, before
it had a chance to achieve any of its objectives, the
Eleventh Crusade was decisively crushed at Nicopolis,
Greece, by Muslim power under the strong Turkish
leadership of Sultan Bayazid I.
Again, 48 years
later the terrorist Europeans organized the Twelfth
Crusade against the Muslim Turks in the Balkans. In
November 1444, however, the forces of Sultan Murad II
quickly repelled the invading Westerners at the
Bulgarian Black Sea port of Varna. In reality, the
Eleventh and Twelfth Crusades were not only miserable
failures that weakened the West, but they also
contributed to the growing strength of Islam. The Muslim
Turks became militarily stronger; captured
Constantinople; destroyed the Byzantine Empire in 1453;
tightened their control over the Balkans; advanced
further into Eastern and central Europe where they
spread Islam; and even occupied southern Italy in
1480-81. Ironically, however, these Turkish Muslim
successes against the invading Westerners took place at
a time when the Arabs themselves were quickly losing
their final foothold in Andalusia to the Spanish
Christians whose Inquisition was yet another form of
Western terrorism against Muslims and Jews.
However, after
the Ottoman Turks took Cyprus in 1570, they suffered
their first major setback in October 1571 when the
Thirteenth Crusade (composed of a combined European
armada) destroyed their fleet at Lepanto (Navpaktos),
near the Greek coast. The Ottomans, though, restored
their fleet within a year. Nonetheless, the Western idea
of launching Crusades and wars against the Arabs and the
Muslim Turks continued well into the 15th, 16th, and
even the 17th centuries. In fact, the violent European
colonization which had started at the end of the 15th
century first against the natives of the Americas,
Australia, New Zealand, Asia, and Africa, eventually
found its way into the weakened Ottoman Empire during
the 19th and early 20th centuries. The Western powers'
destruction of the Ottoman Empire, the last Muslim
empire, at the beginning of the 20th century,
has brought about the current subjugation of the Arabs
to the brutal Western imperialism which created Jewish
Israel in 1948 over the land of Palestine.
XI. The Legacy of the Terrorist Crusaders
By launching
their violent Christian wars against Islam and the
Arabs, the Crusades in fact not only hastened the
destruction of the Arab Abbasid civilization at the
hands of the Mongols, but also indirectly helped bring
about the emergence of Turkish power in Arab and Muslim
lands with the exception of Arab Andalusia, Iran,
Pakistan, and Afghanistan.
Also, thanks to
the cruel Western Crusaders, many Arab Muslims have
become weary of some Arab Christians. The relationship
between the two brotherly Arab communities has since
been somewhat strained. Before the arrival of the
Crusaders in Arab lands, Arab Muslims throughout the
entire Fertile Crescent used to join their Arab
Christian brothers in celebrating Christmas, Epiphany
(the Christian Feast of the Three Kings), Palm Sunday,
and Easter Sunday.
Although the
Crusades were initially launched by the West to unite
Western and Eastern European Christians, as well as to
defeat the Arabs and Islam, they miserably failed on
both accounts. The Crusaders' vicious wars on their
"fellow" Greek Orthodox Christians of Byzantium and
their barbaric destruction of Constantinople during the
Fourth Crusade (1202-1204), brought an effective end to
any serious reconciliation between the Western European
and the Eastern European Christian Churches; seriously
weakened the Byzantine Empire and made it an easy prey
for the Muslim Turks; and discredited the Papacy by
making it lose face among many of its followers.
Moreover, all of
the Crusaders colonies in the Arab world were completely
destroyed. Islam itself emerged from its defensive wars
against the Crusaders to become an even stronger force
under the Turks. The Muslim Turks expanded Islam farther
into Eastern and Southeastern Europe at the expense of
the European Christians in places like Albania and
Bosnia. The final coup de grace came in 1453 when
the Muslim Turks destroyed the Eastern Roman Empire
itself, conquered its great capital city of
Constantinople, renamed it Istanbul, and even made it
their proud capital city for 470 years. In fact,
nowadays Istanbul has some of the most magnificent
mosques in the entire Muslim world, some of which used
to be Byzantium churches such as the great Cathedral
Hagia Sophia, which in 1935 was turned into a Turkish
museum by the current Turkish secular republic.
Nonetheless, the
dark-ages Crusaders - who were a group of savages with
rough manners from the crude castles, fields, and
tangled forests of West Europe - were amazed and dazzled
by the great cultures and civilizations of both the
Arabs and Byzantium that they had invaded. They had an
opportunity to see and experience first hand many new
things and ideas that in time they adopted and
incorporated into their own daily lives. Through their
long brutal crusading wars against Islam, Western
Europeans learned a great deal from the Arabs. For
example, they learned the art of raising and training
carrier pigeons to send messages from town to town, the
sport of falconry, and the Chinese art of papermaking.
Also, Italians adopted the glass-making techniques of
Tyre; French villagers learned the arts both of weaving
lustrous fabrics and of cultivating silkworms; and
farmers throughout Western Europe began to plant sugar
cane from Tripoli and plum trees from Damascus. While
West European men learned to enjoy the sensuous comfort
of Muslim steam baths, their women started using glass
mirrors instead of polished metal disks. Cinnamon,
nutmeg, cloves, cardamom, and other aromatic spices of
the East began to find their way into the dull Western
cookery. Also, many new items such as rugs, silk, ivory,
camphor, musk, and pearls began to appear and to be
appreciated in Europe for the first time after the
Crusades had opened Western eyes to the riches and life
style of the East. In fact, Arab sciences, ideas,
crafts, and skills which reached West Europe - both as a
result of the Crusaders' violent contacts with the Arabs
of the east as well as from Europe's contact with Arab
Andalusia in the west - hastened the West's climb from
the depths of its dark ages.
In addition,
many new Eastern political, economic, and cultural ideas
reached Western Europe and began to change dramatically
the face of the West. Among the most important of these
changes was the emergence in West Europe of a new
merchant class that was hungry for trading with the
Arabs and the East. As this new business class grew in
strength, it began to seriously rival European feudal
lords, knights, and barons both in wealth and social
status. Consequently, the old West European dictatorial
feudal and manorial systems quickly came tumbling down,
and West Europe was no longer backward. The well-known
Italian explorer, Marco Polo - who made his famous
journey to China (1271-1295) immediately after the
Eighth Crusade - not only increased West Europe's
interest in trading with the East, but also inspired
other Western explorers like Christopher Columbus to
search for a direct sea route to India.
As a result of
the centuries of Western conflicts and contacts with the
Arabs, the age of the greedy Western international
capitalism and brutal colonialism/imperialism has
emerged to the detriment and misery of the native
peoples of North America, Central America, South
America, the Caribbean, the Pacific, New Zealand,
Australia, Tasmania, Asia, Africa, and the Arab world.
Hence, the most important legacy of the Crusaders has
been the sanctification of Western violence against
non-Europeans in pursuit of imperialist and capitalist
ends. The underlying concept of European holy wars
against the Arabs and Islam has outlived its religious
origin and has been absorbed in the institutions of
Western governments. When European kings, knights, and
other rich upper classes grew stronger after the
Crusades, they secularized the concept of justifiable
violence and extended it into the politico-economic
sphere. In effect, the Western State has since replaced
the Western Church as a holy cause.
Finally, the
savage Western Crusades against the Arabs were a
starting point of a millennial bitter hostility between
the Arabs and the West and its effects are still
lingering on. The Crusaders' gory massacres and barbaric
cannibalism in the Arab world created a great deal of
hate for the imperialist West which has since been
ingrained in the hearts and minds of most Arabs and
Muslims. And since the 19th century new waves
of Western aggression and wars against the Arabs have
been taking place. Arab hatred for the West, because of
the Crusades, has been painfully re-ignited by the
vicious Western colonization and dismemberment of the
Arab nation during the 19th and 20th
centuries; by the American brutal imperialism and wars
in Arab and Muslim lands; and by the violent creation of
the Western Zionist state of Israel with the help of the
imperialist West over the land of Palestine in 1948.
Instead of
Western Christians, this time Western Zionist Jews have
made a similar dubious claim on Palestine. Using far
more sophisticated deadly weapons than the old
Crusaders, the Zionist-Jews (or the new Western
“crusaders”) have been committing Crusade-like bloody
massacres since 1948 against innocent Palestinians and
other Arabs, both Muslim and Christian. The West has
always been obsessed with stealing the holy land from
the Arabs, and so history repeats itself.
Abdullah Mohammad Sindi
________________
Dr. Abdullah
Mohammad Sindi
(http://members.aol.com/AMS44AMS/)
is a Saudi-American professor of International Relations
and Political Science. He studied in the 1960s and 1970s
in different universities in France, Belgium, and the
USA. He received his BA and MA from California State
University, Sacramento in 1970 and 1971 respectively. In
1978 he received his Ph.D. from the University of
Southern California. Dr. Sindi taught at five academic
institutions: King Abdulaziz University in Jeddah, Saudi
Arabia; University of California at Irvine; California
State University at Pomona; Cerritos College in
California; and Fullerton College in California. Between
his teaching posts he also worked as a research fellow
at the United Nations in New York. Professor Sindi is
the author of many articles published both in Arabic and
English in different journals and periodicals. His book,
The Arabs and the West: The Contributions and the
Inflictions, is sold on Amazon.com
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0967431603/002-0764941-4573669?n=283155
__________________
Notes:
1. James
David Barber, The Book of Democracy (Englewood
Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 1995), p. 178.
2. Paul
Johnson, A History of Christianity (New York:
Atheneum, 1976), p. 242.
3. Quoted in
John L. Esposito, Islam the Straight Path (New
York: Oxford University Press, 1991), p. 60.
4. Quoted in
Hans J. Morgenthau, Politics Among Nations: The
Struggle for Power and Peace (4th ed.; New York:
Alfred A. Knopf, 1966), p. 47.
5. Quoted in
Anne Fremantle, Age of Faith (New York: Time
Incorporated, 1965), p. 55.
6. Quoted in
Jay Williams, Knights of the Crusades (New York:
American Heritage Publishing Co., Inc., 1962), pp.
32-34.
7. Quoted in
Henry W. Ehrmann and Martin A. Schain, Politics in
France (5th ed.; New York: Harper Collins, 1992), p.
5.
8. Anthony
West, The Crusades (New York: Random House,
1954), pp. 18-19.
9.
Fremantle, Age of Faith, p. 56.
10. Karen
Armstrong, Holy War: The Crusades and Their Impact on
Today's World (New York: Doubleday, 1991), p. 3.
11. Quoted
in ibid., p. 3.
12. Amin
Maalouf, The Crusades Through Arab Eyes,
Translated by Jon Rothschild, (New York: Schocken Books,
1984), p. 273.
13. Ibid.,
p. 5.
14. Ibid.,
p. 6.
15. Johnson,
A History of Christianity, p. 246.
16. Anna
Comnena, The Alexiad of the Princess Anna Comnena,
Translated by Elizabeth A.S. Dawes, (New York: Barnes
and Noble, 1967), p. 252.
17. Maalouf,
The Crusades, p. 30.
18. Ibid.,
p. 26.
19. Ibid.,
p. 29.
20. Quoted
in David E. Stannard, American Holocaust: The
Conquest of the New World (New York: Oxford
University Press, 1992), p. 179.
21. Maalouf,
The Crusades, p. 32
22. Walter
Buehr, The Crusaders (New York: G.P. Putnam's
Sons, 1959), pp. 55-56.
23. Maalouf,
The Crusades, p. 36.
24. Ibid.,
p. 37.
25. Quoted
in ibid., pp. 38-39.
26. Quoted
in ibid., p. 39.
27. Quoted
in ibid., p. 40.
28. Quoted
in ibid., p. 39.
29.
Fremantle, Age of Faith, p. 53.
30.
Stannard, American Holocaust, p. 178.
31. Maalouf,
The Crusades, p. 50.
32.
Stannard, American Holocaust, p. 178.
33.
Fremantle, Age of Faith, p. 56.
34. Maalouf,
The Crusades, p. xiv.
35.
Stannard, American Holocaust, p. 179.
36. John J.
Robinson, Dungeon, Fire and Sword: The Knights
Templar in the Crusades (New York: M. Evans and
Company, Inc., 1991), p. 18.
37.
Stannard, American Holocaust, p. 178.
38. Quoted
in ibid., p. 178.
39. Maalouf,
The Crusades, p. xiv.
40. Quoted
in Stannard, American Holocaust, p. 178.
41. Quoted
in Robinson, Dungeon, Fire and Sword, p. 18.
42. Johnson,
A History of Christianity, pp. 246-247.
43. Quoted
in Richard Wormser, American Islam: Growing Up Muslim
in America (New York: Walker and Company, 1994), pp.
7-8.
44. Quoted
in Maalouf, The Crusades, p. 52.
45. Johnson,
A History of Christianity, p. 246.
46. Maalouf,
The Crusades, p. 66.
47. Ibid.,
p. 67.
48. Johnson,
A History of Christianity, p. 246.
49. Ibid.,
p. 246.
50. Maalouf,
The Crusades, p. 88.
51. Ibid.,
pp. 156-57.
52. Johnson,
A History of Christianity, p. 246.
53. Ibid..
p. 246.
54. Quoted
in Maalouf, The Crusades, p. 186.
55. Ibid.,
p. 187.
56. Quoted
in ibid., p. 194.
57. West,
The Crusades, p. 115.
58.
Robinson, Dungeon, Fire and Sword, p. 183.
59. Johnson,
A History of Christianity, p. 246.
60. Buehr,
The Crusaders, p. 94.
61.
Robinson, Dungeon, Fire and Sword, p. 239.
62. Arthur
Goldschmidt, Jr. A Concise History of the Middle East
(Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press, 1988), p. 96.
63.
Armstrong, Holy War, p. 452.
64. Johnson, A History of Christianity, p. 246 |